Mafia 2 - I Left My Heart in San Francisco - Day 4

Funny, its the two mafia members now who want to stall on the lynch. LMAO

awwwww....

derB wrote:

Sir Boydly Boydster wrote:

Either DerB is mafia or just a terrible player.

Now I kind of want to by lynched, with you spearheading the votes, so maybe your comfy throne atop Mount Never-Lynch gets a firm jolt to the rear. "Either Boyd is mafia or really conceited." Doesn't feel good, eh? Makes you want to bite back? That is why I avoid such direct hits, they sidetrack an otherwise enjoyable game. It's pretty easy to think well of yourself when you have never played before, and have never risked your reputation by actually participating in a lynch, let alone made a mistake in the process.

But in all seriousness, I don't want to be lynched, because I do admit, and have admitted, that lynching Thian was a mistake and I bear the majority of the responsibility.

As had been said, we need to be wary of those who would mad-rush into a lynch when a mistake here will cost us the game. We can still talk strategy and discuss our suspicions without slapping votes around like madmen (and madwomen). If two townies cast their votes on the wrong person, the mafia are three posts away from victory.

I AM really conceited. Conceited as I am, I happily admit that. I am also arrogant and can be blunt and downright smug. I'm also full of myself, sarcastic and could be correctly labelled a wise-ass with the emphasis on wise. However I also call it like I see it. So I'm glad you recognize who you are dealing with.

Anyhoo...the rest of your post sounds like you wish to join me on Mount Never-Lynch. theres plenty of room, another stupid lynch will kill another innocent. I am not trying to defame you I just can not understand why you went through with that lynch on thian. NONE of your reasons were plausible. I tried to talk some sense into you - two days in a row. but you doggedly insisted on a lynching, and two inncocents died. i would have voted to lynch three other people before i got to thian. even with my vote on you yesterday you couldnt give me any reason not to lych you. NOW you are saying tap the brakes, lets not be hasty. Where is the cheerleader i used to know. Why are you not on my bandwagon to lynch yourself?

Mandie,

So far, you, derb, cam, boyd, pete, me have all posted since I said I was the nurse. None of you have claimed to be the nurse except boyd in a joking way.


so that only leaves Stacie and Dragonldy. If one of them doesn't say they are the nurse, will you finally believe me?


As far as voting for Cam, I would if I end up thinking he is mafia. But I am not placing my vote right now for reasons I have stated. From my perspective, if someone does claim to be the nurse, they will obviously be mafia. And I will want to vote for them.

Everyone was so gungho and lynch happy at the start of the game when i was trying to tell everyone to Be careful about throwing your votes around, make sure you get it right.... and yall have been so wrong.... Last round and this round, I have been confident. I am confident now, it's not gonna change.

Innocent people stand with me. This is my last plea.

If you HONESTLY think that PhocQ is telling you the truth (he isnt by the way), and you are unsure... (pete im talking to you) VOTE CAM. You can't go wrong. I promise. I promise I promise you.

Mandie Leigh wrote:

Funny, its the two mafia members now who want to stall on the lynch. LMAO

awwwww....

I'm not stalling anything! I just think we should take our time on this because we're donezo if we're wrong. It is very possible that derB is mafia. But it's the first day of the new round and we should really talk this out.

PhocQ wrote:

Mandie,

So far, you, derb, cam, boyd, pete, me have all posted since I said I was the nurse. None of you have claimed to be the nurse except boyd in a joking way.


so that only leaves Stacie and Dragonldy. If one of them doesn't say they are the nurse, will you finally believe me?


As far as voting for Cam, I would if I end up thinking he is mafia. But I am not placing my vote right now for reasons I have stated. From my perspective, if someone does claim to be the nurse, they will obviously be mafia. And I will want to vote for them.

You are mafia and you want to frame the real nurse.

NURSE DONT DO IT.

Mandie Leigh wrote:

PhocQ wrote:

Mandie,

So far, you, derb, cam, boyd, pete, me have all posted since I said I was the nurse. None of you have claimed to be the nurse except boyd in a joking way.


so that only leaves Stacie and Dragonldy. If one of them doesn't say they are the nurse, will you finally believe me?


As far as voting for Cam, I would if I end up thinking he is mafia. But I am not placing my vote right now for reasons I have stated. From my perspective, if someone does claim to be the nurse, they will obviously be mafia. And I will want to vote for them.

You are mafia and you want to frame the real nurse.

NURSE DONT DO IT.

Are you kidding me?

If I didn't know you were innocent I swear to god I would think you were mafia. lol

So if I am to get this right...


None of you even care if I am the nurse or not?

I care and I believe you lol. I just haven't said anything about it since I'm not it.

PhocQ wrote:

So if I am to get this right...


None of you even care if I am the nurse or not?

That's why I haven't changed my vote to you. You are at 95% - the other 5% is now filled with nursiness. I am still 100% sure on DerB and now less likely to switch my vote to you...just in case. Now doesn't that make you fell better....

also, I would rather see a nurses outfit on phillip than those pink nut huggers

Mandie,
I don't know either way to be honest but if you feel confident with PhocQ then I will vote with you for him. I also agree with you that he may be trying to bait the nurse into revealing themselves to take out in the night round. That is a scary thought.

I also find it interesting how the people who will push a lynch in the early rounds expect the people who want to take the time to figure things out in the early rounds to stay to that. Why the switch, I don't get it, but I think when you feel confident in someone being mafia than you should vote for them. You can only go based on what you feel, if anything comes up that makes you change your mind, retract immediately.

Pete wrote:

Mandie,
I don't know either way to be honest but if you feel confident with PhocQ then I will vote with you for him. I also agree with you that he may be trying to bait the nurse into revealing themselves to take out in the night round. That is a scary thought.

I also find it interesting how the people who will push a lynch in the early rounds expect the people who want to take the time to figure things out in the early rounds to stay to that. Why the switch, I don't get it, but I think when you feel confident in someone being mafia than you should vote for them. You can only go based on what you feel, if anything comes up that makes you change your mind, retract immediately.

Pete what you said is not possible.

There is no reason to bait the nurse. If the Mafia indeed were blocked last night, they can kill that person with 100% success tonight and end the game. Who the nurse is is irrelevant. These are facts, not opinion.

If we don't lynch the right person, the game will be over. This is not opinion.

That is the exact advice I have been following Pete. The only two times I have voted are for the two people that I feel confident about being mafia.

Cam or PhocQ , Either one Pete ... they both are mafia.

It's the third Mafia that I am not sure about.

So Im willing to vote Cam or PhocQ. Both are guilty guilty guilty dear.

I believe you PhocQ. At this point, the mafia are so close to winning they wouldn't need to lie about being the nurse. They could just lynch me. I am the easiest target right now, to be sure. I can't blame Boyd for wanting to vote for me, I am just not understanding why, if he is a townie, he is so willing to throw is vote out there when if he is wrong, the mafia can easily capitalize on it and end the game.

I am not saying he should never vote for me, I am just saying that doing so without even discussing anything is a pretty weird move.

And it may well cost us the game.

DerB... LMAO

If you believe PhocQ... you are making ANOTHER mistake.

OMG.

Thats why i suspect you. ... Why.. Why Why... LMAO

Ya know what.....


If the mafia win this game, it will be because NO ONE listened to ME when I was RIGHT. lol

And it will be your own fault. for losing.

Im going to watch TAR that i recorded.

alright Mandie

I vote to lynch PhocQ

I hope you are right thogh, but I definitely trust that you are not mafia so lets take this town back from the mafia. Next round we go for Cam

Pete, please respond to what I said about why the mafia wouldn't care about the nurse.

DEADLINE for Day 4 - Thursday, March 24th - 10:00pm EDT

VOTES: (Majority of 5 needed to lynch)
Derb: 1 Vote of 5 (Sir Boydly)
PhocQ: 2 Vote of 5 (Mandie, Pete)

Pending votes: 5
Cam, derB , Stacie, PhocQ, Dragonldy

He could just say "I intend to vote for derB, but would like to deliberate our options. We can't afford to miss this one" and try to bait out the mafia, if he were a townie. Just an observation.


Then vote for me Mandie. What is stopping you?

For the record, I think Pete, Dragonldy, and Boyd/Stacie are mafia.

Bless you Pete.


I wont let you down.



PhocQ. you are mafia. you are trying to confuse the masses and you are doing a fine job. So pat yourself on the back, you have DerB fooled, or else... DerB IS the last mafia.

Mandie, can you respond to what I said about the mafia calling out the nurse?


What do you think of that I said? How do you think it would benefit the Mafia?


Why do you think I am addressing you the most? It's because I know you are innocent. Please Mandie, just take a step back and humour me for a second. Put yourself in my shoes IF I was telling the truth. Would you not feel exactly as I do now? Frustrated that the only person I know is innocent is about to use me to hand the game to the mafia.

derB wrote:

For the record, I think Pete, Dragonldy, and Boyd/Stacie are mafia.

Where is Thian on your list??? Oh yeah... that's right.

No worries for you though. NOBODY EVER jumps on my bandwagons - thus no mafia has been lynched.

Still not clearly understanding why the nurse would accuse someone during the day who he is going to protect at night.

PhocQ wrote:

Pete wrote:

Mandie,
I don't know either way to be honest but if you feel confident with PhocQ then I will vote with you for him. I also agree with you that he may be trying to bait the nurse into revealing themselves to take out in the night round. That is a scary thought.

I also find it interesting how the people who will push a lynch in the early rounds expect the people who want to take the time to figure things out in the early rounds to stay to that. Why the switch, I don't get it, but I think when you feel confident in someone being mafia than you should vote for them. You can only go based on what you feel, if anything comes up that makes you change your mind, retract immediately.

Pete what you said is not possible.

There is no reason to bait the nurse. If the Mafia indeed were blocked last night, they can kill that person with 100% success tonight and end the game. Who the nurse is is irrelevant. These are facts, not opinion.

If we don't lynch the right person, the game will be over. This is not opinion.

well one of three things happened last night:

1 ~ the nurse blocked the mafia

2 ~ the mafia did a no-kill purposely

3 ~ the mafia did not vote in time or correctly.

Therefore there is no way to know for sure what happened last night. I think the mafia could have done a no-kill in hopes to draw out the nurse and get the nurse out of the way.

If the nurse blocked the mafia, again they are gonna want to figure out who the nurse is to take them out so that they cannot be blocked again. By the mafia revealing that they are the nurse, people usually always believe someone when they say they have a role and vote with that person, so the mafia could have used that as a way to trick the town into accidentally voting for the nurse.

If the mafia didn't vote in time or correctly, well then they must be getting desperate to make sure that they make the right move. To me it would seem that with Thian being innocent that the mafia got cocky and made a mistake and now know that they set themselves up to be targeted this round and will now need to convince two townspeople to vote for them over just the one.

that is what I'm thinking could have happened. Which one do I think most likely. I don't know, I'm not sure I've ever seen a mafia use the no-kill scenario cause I don't think anyone would think that is a good move, so it is one of the other two most likely