Mafia 2 - I Left My Heart in San Francisco - Day 1

okay I'm confused as to what the reason is that people are voting for who they are voting for

Thian, why Cam and not derB?

Tiffani, I do get what you are saying but you are twisting what PhocQ said and that was that you have mostly been a good role therefore the probability of you having an evil role is significantly higher this time (or something along those lines). Not saying I agree with him on that because probability barely ever works out in these games, it is way too random

PhocQ, yes it worked to get Brant out but why would it work to pin point Tiffani as mafia. The difference between the two situations was that Brant had NEVER been mafia/werewolve/etc at that time so it made some since, however Tiffani has had an evil role at least once in the previous few games, so not sure that would work as strongly.

Sir Boydly, also not sure on your reasons for voting for Tiffani, care to elaborate?

I just want to understand where people are coming from more in order to help me make an informed decision of who I think is most likely mafia, and by people answering these questions I think it will also help others as well

Neapolitan Ice Cream
CHOCOLATE


What is your favorite thing about this game?



I usually just like being apart of the game and playing with everyone here.

Pete:
Do you think derB is a better option than Cam right now?

DEADLINE for Day 1 - Tuesday, March 8th - 23:59 EST

VOTES: (Majority of 6 needed to lynch)
Tiffani: 2 vote of 6 (Sir Boydly, PhocQ)
PhocQ: 1 vote of 6 (Tiffani)
Cam: 1 vote of 6 (Thian)

Pending votes: 7
Cam, Mandie, Kyle, Pete, derB , Stacie, Dragonldy

What is your favorite thing about this game?
Being in control and knowing everything.

Thian wrote:

Vote: Cam

Oh shit sonnnnnn! Thian be gettin da fo wun wun!

Yeah I'm not really good at that.

Thian,
honestly I'm not sure which is a better option, don't really feel there is any specific options that are better than any at this point. That is why I want people to give more insight into why they are voting how they are voting, that way there are more ideas out there that could help us figure out where to go

though I gotta say, Cam, are you trying to imply something?

cam has not made much impression currently in the game.

There are several players who have not either. My vote will be floating around them until they either speak up, or get lynched.

Tiffani wrote:

PhocQ wrote:

I'm gonna go ahead and vote to lynch Tiffani. It just seems like Tiffani always has a good role so I'll take a stab in the dark based on the law of averages. (hey, it worked when I lynched Brant a few games ago lol)

You're definitely right, I have always pretty much had a good role, which leads me to think you must be mafia trying to get rid of the good guys early


So I vote to lynch Phoc He flat out said "always has a GOOD role" so why on EARTH would you want to lynch someone with a GOOD role lmao

I didn't say I wanted to get rid of you. I just wanted to vote for someone and law of averages is as good a strategy on day one as any. Then again, I suppose picking names out of a hat is as good a way as any on day 1.

I really don't think Cam is Mafia. Not sure about anyone else. I'm still considering people. I'll come back later and cast a vote.

Pete wrote:

Sir Boydly, also not sure on your reasons for voting for Tiffani, care to elaborate?

I just want to understand where people are coming from more in order to help me make an informed decision of who I think is most likely mafia, and by people answering these questions I think it will also help others as well

You're absolutely right. Complete and full disclosure will help everyone.

I therefore RETACT MY VOTE FOR TIFFANI TO BE LYNCHED

I NOW CAST A VOTE FOR KYLE TO BE LYNCHED

Favorite flavor - chocalate
Favorite reason to play - I guess to throw random death threats at possibly innocent people

DEADLINE for Day 1 - Tuesday, March 8th - 23:59 EST

VOTES: (Majority of 6 needed to lynch)
Tiffani: 1 vote of 6 (PhocQ)
PhocQ: 1 vote of 6 (Tiffani)
Cam: 1 vote of 6 (Thian)
Kyle: 1 vote of 6 (Sir Boydly)

Pending votes: 7
Cam, Mandie, Kyle, Pete, derB , Stacie, Dragonldy

Dragonldy640 wrote:

I really don't think Cam is Mafia. Not sure about anyone else. I'm still considering people. I'll come back later and cast a vote.

You don't think Cam is mafia? Based on what? It certainly isn't from anything he said on this board. So I figure you are saying he isn't a mafia for 1 of 2 reasons. You are mafia or you just don't want to vote him cause you are friends. Either way that's a pretty crappy reason. And I don't like the idea of moving forward with people who will base their votes to lynch off of who they like and don't like.










So I retract my vote for Tiffani



And I vote to lynch Dragonldy.

Dragonldy640 wrote:

I really don't think Cam is Mafia. Not sure about anyone else. I'm still considering people. I'll come back later and cast a vote.

hmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm strange


I retract my vote for Phoc


I vote to lynch Dragonldy

hahahaha Phoc GMTA

A complete list of favorite flavors, along with a voting history up to this point.


CHOCOLATE
Cam
Kyle
Dragonldy
Stacie
Mandie
Boyd - Tiffani, Kyle

VANILLA
derB

STRAWBERRY
Thian - derB, Cam
Pete

ALL OF THE ABOVE
Tiffani - PhocQ, Dragonldy

LL COOL J
PhocQ - Tiffani, Dragonldy

Excluding me, that is a 6:4 ratio, or 3:2, nearly perfect for a 2:1 ratio of mafia scum, two in chocolate, one not.
Of the chocolate lovers, it is statistically likely that neither of them have voted yet. They are also likely trying to hide in the chocolate majority, keeping quiet and only doing what is necessary for their purposes, that is team survival. I have a crazy hunch that one of them even lied to get a spot in this majority as well, knowing I was trying something with this question, but that would only be true of the last half or so of the list.

Of those that did not choose chocolate, they are likely to be outspoken and boisterous, probably trying to separate themselves from the other Mafia as much as possible. It is very statistically likely that they have voted.

Based on these observations, I have ideas about who is what, but I want to let these ideas sink in with everybody and let come what may.

VERY INTERESTING!!!

DEADLINE for Day 1 - Tuesday, March 8th - 23:59 EST

VOTES: (Majority of 6 needed to lynch)
Cam: 1 vote of 6 (Thian)
Kyle: 1 vote of 6 (Sir Boydly)
Dragonldy: 2 votes of 6 (PhocQ, Tiffani)

Pending votes: 7
Cam, Mandie, Kyle, Pete, derB , Stacie, Dragonldy

Well, I'm not Mafia! But since we're getting personal....................


I vote for PHOC!

DEADLINE for Day 1 - Tuesday, March 8th - 23:59 EST

VOTES: (Majority of 6 needed to lynch)
Cam: 1 vote of 6 (Thian)
Kyle: 1 vote of 6 (Sir Boydly)
Dragonldy: 2 votes of 6 (PhocQ, Tiffani)
PhocQ: 1 vote of 6 (Dragonldy)

Pending votes: 6
Cam, Mandie, Kyle, Pete, derB , Stacie

Dragonldy:
What worries me currently about your voting? Are you voting PhocQ because he is voting you?

What has Cam done to wave your suspicion in this game?

Currently, other than PhocQ, if you could objectively look at what has been said between people, is there anything glaring out at you that screams suspicious?


derB:
Your analysing based on flavors?

derB's theory is delicious. See what I did thar??

I don't think it really means anything, but I DO want to look back once this game is over to see if it matches up with who was actually mafia. It'll be hilarious if it was accurate.

Yes, it's suspicious that when Phoc voted me, Tiffani jumped on the bandwagon too for no reason. I suspect both of them, but can only vote for one.

Tiffani wrote:

hahahaha Phoc GMTA

I didnt' jump on any "bandwagon" I didn't even see that he had done the same thing I did until after I posted. What's strange is you clearing Cam immediately without plausible reason and then voted for someone just cuz they voted for you and now are pointing fingers just because I voted for you.