Werewolf 2 - Day 1 - A Meeting of the minds

Again, you'd REALLY regret lynching me lol.

hey everyone, I know I haven't talked a whole lot but I promise you I am no werewolf and will prove it however I need to. I just honestly am not sure what to say or who to accuse cause what do we really have to go by. This round is really just a shot in the dark and I am afraid of making the wrong choice again.

But of course, if we lynch wrong, we lose 2 townsfolk. If we don't lynch we lose 1. If we lynch right we pretty much win lol. So its high risk-high reward.

Yeah. Ultimately, I dont' think it's worth it to not lynch anyone, and I definitely agree with all of you saying that much 100%. We have to kill or be killed. That's the bottom line.

How we kill, it's just going to be random, unless anyone has a strong case for someone in these short moments here.

I am going to withdraw my nomination of Alexander. I couldn't edit the nomination post since Thian had reposted it but I crossed a line through Alexander in the post right below his re-post.


That said, I'm re-nominating because this is getting painful.


I nominate DJ (Kah-Hoo-Foo) for reasons stated previously. He hasn't said much of substance and i still believe it is a huge mistake to not lynch this round.

Second anyone?

Well, people that push nominations are going to have somewhat of a target on their back, because obviously werewolves want to get rid of the townies.

For this reason I'm going to nominate Caligula because he suggested nominating people that haven't spoken (they can't cause too much commotion if they're not around). We also don't HAVE to kill, but he's pushing the issue. Must be that werewolf instinct

Plus, he smells like a wolf.

I think you've got this all backwards, Dogdude.

Why would you want to keep people around who aren't speaking up? They are not helping us at all they are either werewolves wanting to stay UTR or they are just coasting through the game. Either way, that isn't going to help us. At least taking someone out who is not talking gets us closer to knowing who is or isn't a werewolf. People who are afraid of speaking up and getting targeted are just
wanting to coast through the game and not help the town.

Your nomination of Caligula is very suspicious to me for that reason, Dog.

I'm seconding the lynch of Caligula. I agree with everything that was said, and I think we're all in the dark anyway.

Well I am a villager.

Well to anyone who knows of me, and my innocent christian self, and realizes that I'm not someone who should be lynched will definitely not be recieving a nomination or a nomination nod from me for a long time.

In addition, I should add, it would be the wolves that would want to get out people who are pushing people to lynch. That way they can just go through the game eating everyone off, while no one else is pushing people to lynch.

I think werewolves would be some of the more active players in the game because not saying anything would make them look suspicious. That's another reason to target someone who's speaking up and pushing for a lynch. You're suspicious to me too, Jacijs, but I really don't think you're a werewolf, so I've dismissed that notion. Your reasoning has been pretty sound. You could be a wolfy after all, but it's so early.

Just going on what I've been able to read into the situation, which is very little at this stage.

Alrighty, well people will decide if I should be lynched or not, but I think it's pretty obvious that it only makes sense to lynch people in order to have a chance of getting the wolves out.

That said, and having read Caligula's defense...

I vote Yes to lynch.

We could go about this for hours and just argue opposite sides, but it won't really amount to anything. Yes, I'm sticking my neck out by going after someone I believe to be a werewolf. If it comes back to bite me, so be it. But I was tired of nothing happening and no real decisions being made. I'm glad Jacijs was doing this as well, but I just didn't feel like Khufu was a wolf. Maybe he is, who knows, too early.

Caligula wrote:

it only makes sense to lynch people in order to have a chance of getting the wolves out.

Exactly, and I think you're a wolf. It's a hunch. We'll see.

Nominated:
Caligula - Defense made

Votes to Lynch
Dogdude84

Votes to NOT lynch



Pending votes are as follows: MAJORITY Reached at 6 Votes to 4.
Alexander the Great
Bryan
Vastfanatic
Professor Momo
Pete
Jacijs
FaWa
Kenya
Kah-Hoo-Foo

**Snuck in a quick peek to see how things were**

I won't be on tonight or tomorrow, so I'm just gonna go ahead and vote yes to lynching. I agree that someone needs to go, even if it's random.

Caligula wrote:

Alrighty, well people will decide if I should be lynched or not, but I think it's pretty obvious that it only makes sense to lynch people in order to have a chance of getting the wolves out.

I totally agree with this reasoning and don't see anything Caligula has done to warrant his nomination.

I vote NO on lynching

I think the wolfies are just standing up for one another. THAT is suspicious to me.

Spoiler:

Caligula wrote:

Well to anyone who knows of me, and my innocent christian self, and realizes that I'm not someone who should be lynched will definitely not be recieving a nomination or a nomination nod from me for a long time.

1st of all, if you are a villager you should know these statements only make the town suspect you more.

Furthermore, being innocent and a Christian doesn't stop you from getting picked as a werewolf, therefore has nothing to do with the game.

FaWa wrote:

Caligula wrote:

Well to anyone who knows of me, and my innocent christian self, and realizes that I'm not someone who should be lynched will definitely not be recieving a nomination or a nomination nod from me for a long time.

1st of all, if you are a villager you should know these statements only make the town suspect you more.

I was thinking the same thing while I was in the shower! Yes, I think about you guys in the shower.

Dogdude84 wrote:

FaWa wrote:

Caligula wrote:

Well to anyone who knows of me, and my innocent christian self, and realizes that I'm not someone who should be lynched will definitely not be recieving a nomination or a nomination nod from me for a long time.

1st of all, if you are a villager you should know these statements only make the town suspect you more.

I was thinking the same thing while I was in the shower! Yes, I think about you guys in the shower.

*Slowly closes firefox*

like I said earlier I really hate the first round in these games. I really feel that there is no way to know who is a werewolf but as I was with the last game I do feel it is safer to vote yes than to vote no, however with that said, if we don't vote someone out this round then who the werewolf kills should help give us a direction, plus it protects us from killing the seer again first round and they can also help us out.

I'm undecided because I feel either way could be a right decision or a wrong decision, no way to know until after it's decided.

Nominated:
Caligula - Defense made

Votes to Lynch
Dogdude84
Bryan

Votes to NOT lynch
Jacijs

Pending votes are as follows: MAJORITY Reached at 6 Votes to 4.
Alexander the Great
Vastfanatic
Professor Momo
Pete
FaWa
Kenya
Kah-Hoo-Foo

**another little update on where votes are pending / yes / no

LOL Doggie? I am definitely a villager - disappointed that I didn't get a role but not surprised since the host doesn't know me from Adam and would probably not give a brand new person a role when he has no idea if I will even post in the game.

But then, I'm not going to go on the defensive just because you are trying to throw accusations at me to cover your own tracks. I call it like I see it and I think I have been more than open and logical about things. If you feel I am suspicious than please elaborate. I think you are just defensive because I pointed out that wanting to keep inactives in the game can only benefit wolves - so maybe that means you are a wolf?

I have no idea if Caligula is a villager or a wolf - but maybe you know what he is? If so, that makes you a wolf. Bottom line, if Caligula is lynched and turns out to be a villager I would be highly suspect of you.

Hopefully the assignment of roles was random, and I believe it was. But I'm not the host.

Basically, threw out a name to get things rolling. You did the same, I just picked a different person. I'm going to see Iron Man 2 in our awesome deluxe Glenwood town theatre. Peace out!

I understand but the name you threw out makes you look suspicious. I explained my reasoning and you haven't really explained yours. Enjoy your movie.