MAFIA HMM REUNION THREAD!!!

SO just who was the killer?


















































Andy Dick - Killer






CONGRATS JEREMY!

It's very hard for a killer to win the game!











Cast List:
Lindsay Lohan - Kyle
Winona Ryder - Michael
Robert Downey Jr. - Santos
Rob Van Winkle - Niki
Miley Cyrus - Stacie 
Charlie Sheen - Green Monster
Amanda Bynes - Pete
Justin Beiber - Marshall 
Andy Dick - Jeremy




NIGHT ONE
Kyle/Lindsay spy's on Niki - Was told Niki visited someone
Niki/Rob Vanwinkle protects Niki
Santos/Robert Downey Jr. investigates GM - Was told GM Visited No one. 
Lindsay's Message to Robert Downey Jr./Santos - Niki visited Someone
Jeremy/Andy Dick - kills Kyle

NIGHT TWO
Niki/Rob Vanwinkle protects Santos
Santos/Robert Downey Jr. investigates Niki - Was told Niki visited Santos
Jeremy/Andy Dick - Kills Santos - Was told his kill was unsuccessful

NIGHT THREE
Niki/Rob Vanwinkle protects Niki
Santos/Robert Downey Jr. investigates Pete - Was told Pete visited No One. 
Jeremy/Andy Dick - Kills Santos

NIGHT FOUR
Niki/Rob Vanwinkle protects Pete
Jeremy/Andy Dick - Kills Niki

NIGHT FIVE
Jeremy/Andy Dick - Kills GM

Good game Jeremy, perhaps I lynched too soon. Still not as good as I could be at it. But great game. I think you had us all fooled.

I think too many people cleared Jeremy way to early on and that guaranteed that he'd win. Had I been on I would have voted Marshall so it really wouldn't have mattered. Way to go Jeremy!!!

Way to go Jeremy.  It is super hard for a Killer to win!!  Good Job..  
Shame on y'all for thinking it was me..   lol 
Seriously, that was fun!

Omg I'm honestly shocked lol! Congrats Jeremy!!

Good game, everyone

Very well played Jeremy, excellent job. Why you gotta kill a brutha night one?   All good, I enjoyed watching the game very closely afterwards. Ready for the next one!

Well done Jeremy

To everyone else, sorry that I am not better at this. I do get the concept, just not very good at the game, and not helped by being otherwise preoccupied. I suck at life.

Really well done though Jeremy, to have everyone so well fooled.

Thanks for putting on the game again, Amanda. <3

Green Monster wrote:

Well done Jeremy

To everyone else, sorry that I am not better at this. I do get the concept, just not very good at the game, and not helped by being otherwise preoccupied. I suck at life.

Really well done though Jeremy, to have everyone so well fooled.

Thanks for putting on the game again, Amanda. <3

Dude, don't sweat it all. Try again next time, maybe you will get a night role and will be able to get more involved

GM, I'm not very good at this game either.. lol obviously!

Thanks for the great game, everyone!  I wanted to share a few things with you all now that the game is over.

First, when I said that Amanda had to remind me of the game on facebook- I wasn't lying.  She told me I had an hour to make my first kill.  :D

 Second, once I saw the cast list, and that I was a killer for the second time in a row (and the second time ever for me), I decided I wanted to make a sequel to what Shanna and I started last time I played.  In that game, Kyle was the one who kind of figured out I was a killer pretty early on.  So, I killed him first out of revenge- and the fact that it would probably be easiest for him to see through whatever I was trying to do.  I then focused on Pete and Stacie- the other two players left from that game- working toward pointing fingers at them ("Who knows Kyle the best?") and trying my best to make this a horror/slasher movie for them both.  Here are my PM kills:

First Kill wrote:

I'm killing Kyle

After the game was over, he told me I'd get him, "next time."  And no matter how many times I reconsidered, everything kept pointing toward a Kyle kill tonight.  So that's where I'm heading.

Second Kill wrote:

Killing Santos

He just made a list of three suspects, including a fourth 'unnamed' suspect.  This could go one of two ways- either this further incriminates the three suspects, or it makes them look innocent because why would they go after him so directly?  I think it'll be the first one, based on how easily people reacted to my 'Going after Kyle because he's smart' thing.

Third Kill wrote:

Killing Santos again.  His rivalry with Pete should throw some heat on my red herring.

Fourth Kill wrote:

Killing Niki

She's been the most vocal about my innocence, so a Niki kill would not arise suspicion toward me.  I'm also 45% sure she is the bodyguard, and if she is, this round would presumably be a vulnerable one for her.

Fifth Kill wrote:

Killing Green Monster

I guess Pete became my final girl.

Thanks again-  you all were a blast to play with.

Hah, I forgot I told you that. Well, you delivered  . Great game for only your second time being a killer. I'm yet to be successful as one so I know how difficult it is.

Being the first out, Im ready to play again.......