MAFIA HMM DAY 3

What the heck?  So the killer didn't kill anyone.. interesting.  I wonder who didn't make it on yesterday.

Bodyguard saved them I'm assuming, else the killer didn't really kill anyone. Well at least the bodyguard knows two clears instead of one now.

I'm guessing the body guard saved them. 

We need to come together this round! 

I'm still suspicious of Michael cuz he's been much quieter than usual.

Yeah I spaced on last round.  Sorry kids.

Anywho, I'm back now.  I gotta get used to checking the site again

Does anyone have a screen-cap of the people who were on during Night 2?  It probably was the bodyguard though, you're right.

this will probably be my only post today as I'm leaving for work shortly (I might come online before bed tonight but not sure).

Anyways, I agree that it was either the bodyguard saved someone or the killer didn't submit a name, thinking the bodyguard saving someone is more likely. I'm having a hard time trying to figure people out this time, and really am not sure who is more suspicious than anyone else. There are some things that have made me think certain people have certain good roles but I don't wanna out those right now obviously.

Oh yah, the body guard, I forgot..  He/She probably did save someone.  I don't have a screenshot. Wish I did.

I don't have a screen shot either, but when I checked the "users active in the last 24 hours" box this morning, I believe everyone in the game was listed.

well we gotta figure something out here so in order to get some conversations going I vote for Stacie

Really not sure why I wanted to vote Stacie other than the fact that I think she plays this game brilliantly every time she plays and is someone to keep an eye on.

Long day... Glad to see we all made it through the night.

A wee bit surprised at the same time. So what now? Who first though of the bodyguard as having saved the day? Could that be a clue as to who the kiler is, as they were thwarted? idk?  

I'm not getting any killer reads at this current moment, come on Santos, we needs you to asks good questions, you play this game extremely well from my experience as well. Though I have yet to see him as the mafia.

lol, Thanks Pete..  I think!   

I also think we need to get some good questions rolling.  
That's the part I'm not good at... figuring out what to ask.

Green Monster wrote:

Long day... Glad to see we all made it through the night.

A wee bit surprised at the same time. So what now? Who first though of the bodyguard as having saved the day? Could that be a clue as to who the kiler is, as they were thwarted? idk?  

Only the body guard would know who the killer tried to kill..

We know the killer killed Kyle round 1. If the body guard came forward with the name of the person they saved last night, then we will know who the killer tried to kill last night.. (which could provide further clues, plus that person the killer tried to kill we would know is innocent) but, I'm not sure if it's a good time for the body guard to come forward or not. What do you guys think?

Also, the detective should have some info by now.. even if it's just the names of a couple innocents. But again, not sure if it's too early to reveal this info..

Regardless we gotta do SOMETHING. We cannot let this go another night with no lynch.

I reread the first two days and at this point, I believe that Santos, GM, and Jeremy are innocent. I doubt Jeremy would forget about the game and need to be reminded by PM from Mandie, if he was the killer.. (or if he had any night role for that matter).. he's most likely an innocent with no role. GM seemed pretty confused at first.. of course that could be an act, but I think he was genuinely confused about the day/night stuff, and he just doesn't strike me as the killer.. Santos is playing the way he plays when he's innocent/has a good role.

Michael I'm still a bit suspicious of. I know he says he spaced on last round, but he was here the first round, but a lot less vocal than usual. And he posted once this round, just saying he was sorry for spacing..  but didn't add anything.. not even a thought about the no-kill last night. it's just very unlike Michael to not suggest anything/speak up much. In the other games I've played with him on here, he usually is pretty smart and vocal about his ideas.. Of course, I could be wrong and he could just be busy, but it's almost as if he's trying to stay under the radar.. which a killer would be smart to do.

Pete I am not sure about. I think he's kinda in the middle for me.. 50% chance he's the killer, 50% chance he's innocent.. He has made some comments that lead me to think he's innocent, such as not wanting to lynch anyone too quickly/wanting to think things through first (whereas the killer would prob just wanna lynch so he gets another townie kill), and also his comment about thinking he knew some of the other night roles IE bodyguard/detective, but didn't wanna say anything and out anyone. But Pete is also super smart, and would have been a likely candidate to kill Kyle first.. so like I said, I am not sure, but I do think Michael is a lot more likely the killer. 

Stacie I am not sure about either. She is playing like she usually plays, but when she is the killer she plays the same way, so it's hard to tell. She was open to lynching on the first night, which the killer would prob wanna do (as long as the vote is not on THEM), but she did retract her vote from Jeremy, which the killer prob wouldn't do.

Marshall is another tricky one. He's relatively new here, but he mentioned he'd been playing epic mafia lately and seems like he's got a lot of practice with mafia games lately, so I think he could be one to watch as well. I don't necessarily see anything he said that was suspicious, but I don't see any clues to him definitely being innocent either.



So what does everyone else think?

WE NEED DISCUSSION PEOPLE! I don't wanna let the killer just pick us off one by one!

that is all some very good observations Niki. One thing I have to strongly stress is that it is WAY to early in the game for the detective or the bodyguard to let us know who they are. They basically would just be letting themselves be the next to die. I do have an idea who may be both roles and that is definitely helping me with who I vote for.

Initially I voted for Stacie basically cause she was the first to post this day and she doesn't seem to be definitely innocent. Something about the way she has been posted seems differently than other games. Maybe I'm remembering wrong lol

I definitely have to agree with you regarding Michael, he is usually one of the more vocal and is not currently being vocal at all, though that makes me feel that he isn't that invested and if he had a role he'd put more effort into the game.

Yeah I understand your point on Stacie, Pete. She doesn't seem completely innocent to me either. 

At the point we must lynch someone and my main suspect is Michael,but am willing to discuss other options.

Aww shucks you guys!!  I just haven't played in a while.. but I can assure you, I am no killer.  I promise!  

Now lets figure out who the real killer is...

I am going to VOTE FOR MICHAEL. 


For me, I remember him being way more vocal in games and having an opinion on people.. and maybe he is just busy in RL, but for now.. I think it's viable!

OK, so we have til tonight to come together and lynch someone. We need five votes. Let's get the ball rolling, guys. We need to do SOMETHING. We can't just assume we will get lucky and have another no kill tonight. We have to strike first.

I vote to lynch Michael.

Deadline for day 3
Monday, March 24th 11:59pm EST

Majority Needs 5 votes.


Votes:
Michael 2 votes of 5 - Stacie, Niki
Stacie  1 vote of 5 - Pete 




Pending Votes: 5
Green Monster, Jeremy, Marshall, Michael, Santos, 



Deadline tonight at 11:59est.