Witches 5 ~ The Supernatural Day Four

Another day done, and still not sure what is going on still, everyone heads to bed.

Neva is completely devastated over losing Cody still, while everyone keeps their distance as she gives them all an attitude

Mallory and Serena both use their detective work to figure things out. One as a ghost and the other by tracking.

Mathew spends a few moments doing what he can to protect one person for the night. Katy is laying down next to Mathew, just happy to be next to him.

The gunman, Darryl, keeps an eye on everyone, prepared to shoot should anyone attack him!

Marylou starts trembling in her sleep as the witch smiles at everyone. Knowing one is about to bite the dust, Carmella is feeling as confident as ever.

Clayton gets up, and while everyone is still in the room he is confident that he can feed on someone without waking anyone. He scopes out everyone, trying to figure out who is more asleep, and who would sleep through anything. He sets his sights on one, sure that he can succeed...

...in the morning, everyone is woken up by a scream. Mathew is sitting there covered in blood, screaming that Katy is dead!

MARSHALL is out! 8 remain, what'll you do next?!

Deadline for Day 4
Saturday, June 23rd, 9pm EST

Majority Needs 5 votes.

Votes:

Pending Votes: 8
Amanda, Donna, Kiwi, Belasen, Niki, DJ, Henry, Kyle


9 ~ Marshall (Katy Tague, Hopeless Romantic)
10 ~ Jordan (Allan Boxer, Drunken Bodyguard)
11 ~ Michael (Cody Vanderploeg, The Troublemaker)
12 ~ Debani (Alejandra Junious, The Werewolf)
13 ~ Santos (Javier Matthes, Vampire's Slave)

I'll be the first to admit i feel like a dolt for lynching Jordan.

I VOTE TO LYNCH DJ

Something has been bugging me about dj...he's playing alot like last game when he was a witch ...only posting once per round and throwing a vote in here and there .....so if it looks green and smells like cheese its a witch

I VOTE TO LYNCH DJ.


Explain yourself ho.

I've been throwing in a vote "here or there" because...we have nothing else to build upon! The two bad guys have no idea who the other is, so it's not like they're collaborating, and the witch is reliant upon the vampire for the night kill. So we have one who has all the power, and the other who is a sitting duck/figurehead until all the rest of the baddies die.

I'm not really sure how I've been much different than anyone else? I've voted with the majority both times, which, if that makes me suspicious then maybe you should have a look at everybody else? I sealed the vote on Debani, and he was a bad guy, sue me for helping my fellow townspeople out. I voted for Jordan because he called me out and called everybody stupid. I'm not going to stand for that.

My vote is for Belasen

To be honest Bela Bela, people have made a few good points throughout this game so far and right now you are my #1 (in my heart and in my suspect list )

And Kiwi, would I really go ahead and kill all the "silent" people first again? That seems pretty stupid for someone like me. Maybe you should read a little bit better into my posts to know that I was pretty busy last day round and didn't have a ton of time to contribute 10 posts. If you want me to speak up, my pleasure. Game on.

And Mandie, don't think you're not suspicious either ho! You're right up there with Sean.

Deej! I am shocked and offended lol but seriously I'm no baddie...

Aw poor Marshall

What makes things tricky is the fact that the we have no clues whatsoever as to who the witch is.. we can only think about who the Vampire might be, based on the last two night kills (Michael and now Marshall). I find it interesting that first the Vamp killed Michael, someone who has been around the site a while, and as many people have said, is smart, and then next round after everyone kept saying that whoever killed Michael must know him well, then the vamp goes and kills Marshall, a newbie who doesn't really know anyone.. almost like they thought about what everyone had said.

I was frustrated reading what went down last round with Jordan being lynched. I was out for most the day and by the time I had a chance to get online and read everything over, the round had ended, and Jordan was lynched. I was frustrated cuz after reading through what I had missed, I honestly didn't think Jordan was a baddie. When Mandie was so convinced he was, I thought hmm she usually isn't so insistent on lynching someone at random, so maybe she knows something.. but I still wasn't convinced.. then after reading what I had missed, my gut screamed to me that Jordan was innocent. When Jordan has a bad role, he tends to act more calm and get less offended because he knows he IS bad, but when he has a good role he tends to get worked up and upset and hurt by people's accusations. My gut told me that Jordan was innocent, and I was correct, as I was when my gut told me Debani was guilty.

Also, I apologize for posting in Jordan's thread after the topic was locked.. I wasn't thinking clearly cuz I was just pretty upset at the way people just blindly lynched him, cuz I'm emotional too and felt bad for the guy.. yeah I know it wasn't right of him to call people names, but we all know he didn't mean it.. he's a lovable guy and wouldn't ever wanna hurt anyone, he just lets his emotions control him sometimes, as do I. But for the record, the only thing I had posted in there was that I was out food shopping and missed all the chaos and personally wish people hadn't lynched Jordan so fast.. I didn't know that the round had definitely ended yet, as I thought maybe it was locked due to the drama so I just wanted to get that out.

Honestly, I am looking at those who were so gungho on lynching Jordan last round without much evidence..

Mandie, I love you dearly.. you are an amazing person.. a great admin/host and I HATE to say this.. but I am honestly kinda suspicious of you at this point.. you just seemed very gung-ho on lynching Jordan.. and it's usually not like you to throw someone's name out there like that unless you know something (which you didn't cuz he was innocent).. like, I remember that one game we all lynched Debani like dummies when he was the detective but you stood your ground and didn't lynch cuz you weren't convinced.. I could be wrong, and I am deeply sorry if I am (please don't take offense to this girl), but I am thinking maybe you could be a baddie..

Sean seems a tad suspicious to me as well.. not sure what to think about him.

Donna has been completely silent, but I know she's been sick. Does anyone know what her status is?

Kiwi I was suspicious of before, cuz he was acting differently than usual, but as people said, he could have a good role.

I can understand people's suspicions of DJ a bit, however, I know he's had a lot going on so that could be why he hasn't posted a whole ton.

As far as Henry goes.. really not suspicious of him much at all. (LMAO if he ends up being a baddie).

What is everyone's thoughts?

Mandie,

I'm still around. I'll try to be more active. I've been reading everything. Both DJ and Belasen seem suspicious to me. I have to go out today and will come back later tonight and see what comes up.

Belasen wrote:

Deej! I am shocked and offended lol but seriously I'm no baddie...

Prove it!

Deadline for Day 4
Saturday, June 23rd, 9pm EST

Majority Needs 5 votes.

Votes:
DJ 2 Kiwi, Amanda
BELASEN 1 DJ

Pending Votes: 5
Donna, Belasen, Niki, Henry, Kyle

Donna wrote:

I'm still around. I'll try to be more active. I've been reading everything. Both DJ and Belasen seem suspicious to me. I have to go out today and will come back later tonight and see what comes up.

Glad to hear you're from ya. How are you feeling?

I feel silly for voting out Jordan, obviously. Near the end there, I started having serious doubts but I figured, well, we gotta find SOMETHING out. We did...it just was the wrong something.

I think I agree with Donna that DJ and Belasen are suspicious, but as to precisely why, Im not even sure. My gut, I guess. With Marshall dead I don't know WHO the hell it is. Killing Michael then Marshall, either the person like Niki suggested, killed him just cause it doesn't throw suspicion on anyone? Or are they just trying to be tricky and random?

I'm busy tonight but I'll be back later to see if anything materialized.

Niki, I know I seem suspicious. I can't change that. I feel terrible for being wrong about Jordan,. but there is no way in hell I would have killed Michael.

And for the record, Belasen is also near the top of my suspect list.

Amanda wrote:

Niki, I know I seem suspicious. I can't change that. I feel terrible for being wrong about Jordan,. but there is no way in hell I would have killed Michael.

I feel so bad for saying that.. I love you. I hope I didn't offend ya.. *hug* Just trying to play the game to the best of my ability.

I do not think you are the Vamp.. I don't think you would have killed Michael off, or Marshall for that matter (seeing he's new and you're really the only person he knows, so you'd feel bad). However, I was thinking maybe you could be the witch, but of course I could be wrong.

I don't think Donna is the vamp because she's been sick so not around as much (I don't remember her posting at all, or maybe just once last round), so she probably wouldn't have gotten her night kill in on time.. but she could be the witch.. I won't count that out.

At this point I am thinking Kiwi probably has a good role.. maybe the detective, as he is more serious this game and less silly, and not as adamant about lynching right away.. before, I thought this was cuz he was a baddie and was worried he'd accidentally lynch his fellow baddies, but as people suggested, this could be because he has a good role.. so I'm leaning towards that now but of course, won't count him out.

I don't suspect Henry at this point.. I think he's a normal person with no good or bad role. Of course, though, not counting him out completely.. I can't completely count out anyone lol.

I am thinking the vamp is either Sean or DJ, and the witch is Mandie (or possibly Donna). Those are my thoughts.

What do you guys think?

okay, I relooked at the roles. Here they are:

Serena: mayor/tracker
Mallory: seer (detective)
Matthew: nurse
Katy: townie: MARSHALL
Darryl: gunman
Cody: townie: MICHAEL
Neva: townie
Allen: bodyguard: JORDAN
Marylou: witch's double
Javier: vampire's slave: SANTOS
Clayton: vampire
Alejandra: werewolf: DEBANI
Carmella: witch


One interesting thing I noticed upon rereading the roles was Katy's (Marshall) role:

Quote :

Katy has no night role, HOWEVER, she will die if Mathew is killed

This makes things very interesting.. am SO glad I reread stuff cuz I had TOTALLY forgotten about this..

So.. this COULD mean that Matthew was the ACTUAL target of the vamp last night (whoever Matthew is), and Katy died in his place. So whoever is Matthew may wanna think about who would wanna kill them, and that may give them a clue as to who the vamp is.

So I looked at who is remaining in this game, along with the remaining roles:

Serena: mayor/tracker
Mallory: seer (detective)
Matthew: nurse
Darryl: gunman
Neva: townie
Marylou: witch's double
Clayton: vampire
Carmella: witch

People remaining:

Amanda
Donna
Kiwi
Belasen
Niki
DJ
Henry
Kyle

Out of these, we have two baddies (the vamp and witch), two detective type roles (the seer and tracker), a nurse, the gunman (who gets to fire a shot at someone when they die), the witch's double (who is innocent but will appear to have visited whoever the witch visited if tracked by the tracker), and one regular townie.

Any ideas as to who could be who? Anyone who wants to give up their role?

Oh and one more thing (sorry for typing so much but I wanna solve this!).. whoever IS Matthew (the nurse).. if I were you, I'd protect yourself tonight, as most likely, the Vamp will want to come after you again, because if they did go after you last round and Katy (Marshall) died in your place, chances are they were planning on trying again to target you.. so this way they will be forced to take a shot in the dark and instead of killing the nurse, could possibly kill the witch (seeing they don't know who eachother are) or the normal townie or witch's double instead (no offense to these people.. but we need our nurse lol)

Not upset at all niki no worries. I promise dear.


My top two suspects are Bela and DJ at this point.

I am never a fan of revealing roles unless its absolutely necessary and your ass is on the line. So I wont be asking the tracker/seer to reveal information but I hope that they have learned enough to know that I am not a baddie.

Which leads me to believe that you Niki, are not the tracker/seer. Or else you would have already investigated me and you would by now know what my role is.

My guess is that you are the witches double.

I havent gotten a bad vibe from you yet.

Ahh this is getting hard.

Okay.. I'm not clearing Mandie yet, but if she is a baddie, she's definitely the witch and not the Vampire. And at this point, there should be more clues telling us who the vamp is seeing he is the one doing all the killings. My gut is telling me the vampire is either DJ or Sean. I really don't know which one to vote for at this point.. I need to go back and reread things before I make a decision.

One note though.. Mandie- do keep in mind that the witch doesn't visit anyone at night right now.. only the vamp does that.. so if the tracker investigated you and was told you visited noone, that would mean you're not the vamp, but that you could still be the witch.. it would also mean you're not the seer, nurse, or tracker, as they all have roles where they visit someone at night too. Not sure if the gunman actually visits someone.. and then there's also the townie Neva and the witch's double who visits whoever the witch visits (who at this point, is noone.)


but the seer, however, could investigate you and be told your role.. so hopefully they will do that soon so we can clear you if you are innocent.

Id be shocked if the tracker/seer hasn't checked on me yet. That's why I am so sure it's not you, or you would know

Mandie, go up and read my post again.. I had to edit it to explain something else..

I was under the impression that if the tracker tracked the witch, or the witches double that they would be given the same information as if they had just tracked the vampire. If I am wrong someone clarify for me please. The only one that is going to know for sure my role is going to be the seer. Whomever that person is, I am sure knows I am not the baddie by now. As for the gunman, I don't know if they actually visit someone or not especially if they arent killed then they technically don't kill anyone either therefore no action would be present.

Pete- could you clarify a few things please?

When the seer visits the witch's double, will they appear as the witch?

As far as the tracker is concerned.. Does the witch/witch's double appear to visit the same person the vamp visits?

And also, am I correct that until the Vamp is killed, the witch has no role whatsoever in the killing?

Also a few questions for a couple people:

Henry: who do you suspect right now?

Kyle: I totally forgot you were still in the game until I relooked at the roles and cast list.. cuz you have been pretty quiet, lol.. who do you suspect?

Donna: first of all, I hope you're hanging in there and feeling okay! My question for you is.. do you suspect anyone besides DJ and Sean? And also, is there anyone you think is definitely innocent?

Kiwi: Who do you suspect? Is there anyone you are pretty sure is innocent?

Mandie: I know you suspect DJ and Sean, and think that I am an innocent townie, and I believe you mentioned a couple rounds back that you didn't suspect Kiwi either.. so what are your thoughts on Henry, Kyle and Donna?

Henry I get an innocent vibe from. His thoughts seem to me to be in line with a townies thoughts.
Kyle, hasn't said enough for me to form an opinion on yet. I think I mentioned somewhere I haven't ruled him out yet.
Donna, I aint feeling her as a baddie. But, maybe that's cause she is quiet. Sometimes people can't read her , but I've always thought I have a pretty good handle on where she stands in games. I aint feeling it. Doesn't mean I'm not wrong, look what I did to jordan.