Witches 3 ~ Chaos - Day 3

As the sun rises on this third day of the end of everything we try and get one step closer to the saving everything. Did the nurse protect the correct person? or Did the Evil Witches take out the nurse?

As the Ten people remaining gather around they all look at one another, waiting for something to happen...

...and nothing happens

Deadline for Day 3
Thursday, Oct 27th, 8pm EST

Majority Needs 6 votes.

Votes:

Pending Votes: 10
Doggerz, Belasen, DJ, Kiwi, Niki, Zack, Mandie, Santos, Staciekins, Donna

11 ~ Kyle (Dean Winchester - Investigator) {Witches Kill}
12 ~ Debani (Merlin - Seer) {Town Exiled}

nothing happened?

that must mean the witches tried to kill whoever the nurse protected!

if we can figure out who the nurse was most likely to protect (the person the witches tried to kill), that may be able to give us a clue as to who the witches are, based on who they wanted to kill.

Alrighty nursey, who did you protect? lololol

In all seriousness though, it would allow us to clear two people (nurse and protectee). I don't know if this is the time to come out with that information though, as it would likely get the nurse killed.

I think that Santos was being genuine in his defense as he was almost killed last round. I hate to possibly be wrong down the road, but in my opinion, we should look elsewhere. As I mentioned last time with my Stacie vote (nothing personal), I think we need to focus on the people that are really just trying to blend in. People that are saying enough to stay active, but not enough to be incriminated later on.

Hey it's all good, I know it's just a game.

BTW, I know I am a bandwaggoner, and I am doing my best to not just "blend in," however, it is hard for me, because I am not good at asking questions. So then, when someone else asks one, I then think "oh thats a good question" and then I make my own opinions of them.

I don't think it would be smart for the nurse to come out right now, she'd most likely be killed for sure!!

Wow

Nice work nursey, way to stop the witchy poo's in there tracks.....now its time to do our job and weed out the witchs

Wow! Thanks to the Nurse for saving someone! Maybe she could hint at who she saved, so we don't vote them out. Of course the witches might try to fool us too. We need to figure out who the witches wanted to get out last round that the Nurse would want to save.

yeah i don't want the nurse killed either, but if we figure out who the nurse protected, that can lead us to the witches.

let's all put ourselves in the nurse's place. and think, based on last round, who would you save? if we figure out who the nurse probably saved, then we can go on to think about who would want to kill that person and maybe lead us to the witches.

i'm gonna go back through and read last round for clues, but have to write a short paper first, so will post my thoughts sometime later today. ^_^

Santos wrote:

I have a question for you Pete


Is it mandatory for the witches to have a kill every round or is there a way that they can send a no kill as well

There are only 2 ways for there to be no kills, nurse protects or witches don't all send in a name and I guess a 3rd reason: not agreeing.

interesting... so it doesn't necessarily mean the nurse protected the right person.

either way we were lucky in getting through a witches rounds and all surviving!

Donna I have a question for you - why do you think you were silenced last round???

Oh wow so it doesn't even mean that the nurse protected the person the witches wanted to kill.. They could've not agreed.

Hello everyone. So, the witches failed to make a kill. Did the other witch fail to send in a name to silence someone as well this round?


Someone asked a brilliant question to Donna. Why do you think that you were silenced last round.


Also, Santos, lots of finger pointing in your direction the last two rounds, what do you make of that?

Also, nurse, I dont think it's a good time for you to come out and say who you are. You are valuable to us and surely will be killed.

Belasen wrote:

Donna I have a question for you - why do you think you were silenced last round???

I have no idea why I was silenced last round. I really don't talk that much and I wasn't onto anything. Maybe they wanted to make me look suspicious so that everyone votes me out. I'm not a witch, so please don't be suspicious of me.

I just thought of something. Pete- do the three witches all have to send in the SAME name for the person to be killed?

Because there is a chance that if one of the witches were an inactive then they may not have sent their choice in by the deadline.

We could possibly look at inactives if this was the case.. specifically (and I could be wrong).. I have noticed Zack as been VERY busy lately (not his fault.. people have lives), but my point is... in the craps game, DJ has to keep reminding him to either roll, vote, etc.. so perhaps he is one of the witches and didn't send his vote in on time. Specifically, if he is the witch who can silence people, that could be why noone was silenced OR killed this round. Again, NOTHING against Zack.. just a thought..

Very interesting point there Niki....

I agree, that's an excellent point Niki!

yeah and honestly, after rereading through everything, i am starting to think santos really was just framed (and not a witch), because after his fight with debani it was easy and the witches probably jumped on that. also, the fact that he asked pete the question above about the witches leads me to think he's most likely not a witch if he asked that question.. i know some people may say "oh, he asked the question to throw us off" but i honestly don't think santos would have thought to do that.. no offense to him, but he doesn't seem like the type to overthink things that much.. and more just to the point. also, donna being silenced still confuses me from last round.. but that is exactly what the witches wanted.. us to be confused.

as of right now my main focus is on inactive people, because i think it's more likely that the witches didn't all agree on a vote in time/all send in the vote, then the fact that they tried to kill the protected person.. because when you think about it, noone was silenced EITHER, and i don't think it's possible for the witches to kill AND silence the same person (you can't silence a dead person) so i'd think even if the nurse protected the person they wanted to kill, they still would've silenced someone.. it only makes sense that there was some inactivity there. Zack stands out to me here seeing he's been one of the last people to roll the die/send in votes in dj's game and posts in this witch game very seldom.. but i will have to read through to see who else doesn't post a whole lot or has been busy lately.

again, none of this is meant to be personal.. i love everyone. just wanna win the game for us investigators and take out the witches.

if anyone else knows of someone who they didn't see post much this weekend (IE the period which the votes were supposed to be cast) let us know.

I thought that Zack seemed suspicious because he was the one that pointed out that three people who accused Santos were either gone or silenced. To me that seemed a bit witch-y. Maybe it was an innocent comment but I felt like I was being led to be wary of Santos when again, I still havent seen anything that Santos has done to make him suspicious. I voted for Zack last round and I will probably vote for him this round unless he convinces me he is innocent or someone else emerges and appears more suspicious than he does to me.

Niki wrote:

I just thought of something. Pete- do the three witches all have to send in the SAME name for the person to be killed?

yes, they all have to send in the same name, if one doesn't send or if all 3 don't send the same name, then no kill would be the result

Amazing point right there Niki . Then there is a chance that Zack is a witch because he has been inactive .

alright, i am definitely thinking zack is a witch then (no offense bud).

and mandie, i wasn't suspicious of that santos comment made by zack last round (zack wasn't even on my radar!) because he could have been on to something i thought.. however, the fact that none was killed OR silenced means there must have had to be an inactive as one of the witches cuz even if the witch protected the right person, the witches STILL would have silenced someone (cuz the same person cannot be killed AND silenced) like i said so that is why Zack is my number one suspect now. I did look at the board stats and noticed he did post thursday saying he voted santos and wouldnt be around that night, but then the next post by him (anywhere on the board, according to the board stats) was not until later sunday AFTER the deadline). if this is wrong someone correct me.. also, he was been posting today in other topics but not in here cuz maybe he's a bit flustered cuz our suspicions, lol.

Wow. That was a lot to read... Very good point Niki.

I thought about the three witches not agreeing, but I don't see how that would benefit them. You'd think they would all at least want someone out... therefore, my guess is that one didn't vote (I.E. your inactive guess).