Witches 2 ~ Hocus Pocus Day 5

I think Tiff has hinted that she's the nurse, or salt girl or whatever. Even if Kyle is the final witch, which I think he is, he can't be eliminated during this day round.

Mandie you's crazy Why do you think Kyle is innocent? You keep saying JJ or Phoc is the witch.

Its still important we get this vote right but it isnt the end of the world if we are wrong on which of the 3 it is. The key is if we lynch the wrong one of the three, that in the following night phase the nurse keep one of the kids safe and the blocker has a 50/50 chance if he chooses between the other 2 remaining suspects. Those are tough odds for the witch to nail one of the kids in the night but not impossible. I think the witch would have to attempt to go after one of the kids too to get the free day pass the following day as their identity will be getting narrowed down quickly at that point. Hope that makes sense

It's Tiffani, she thinks that Kyle is innocent. She ruled him out.

And Yall have all ruled out each other (jordo/cam).

And no one here listens to me.

SO ... if Tiffani is wrong and Kyle is still a suspect then its Kyle phoc Or JJ.

Yall still have to pic someone.

Tiffani Jordan and Cam, the three of you need to agree on someone. Either Kyle is or isnt innocent.

Caroling Cam wrote:

The blocker has been eliminated though, it was Donna.

I thought that that was the bodyguard. I need to go reread the roles

Reading back, it is possible that Tiff's scenario happened. With Kyle being targeted by the witch, Tiff saving Kyle, and Jordan blocking Kyle. I want to hear more from Jordan about all of this besides his simple vote on Kyle.

Oh yeah Kyle you're right, the bodyguard was eliminated (Donna). I got my roles mixed up. I thought Tiff/Pete's posts said bodyguard, haha.

Ugh. I retract My Vote For Myself. I did it out of frustration. I don't want to give up because I feel we are so close. I do really want to help yall figure it out unfortunately I dont have anything. I have to go by what yall say and figure out. I can't investigate. I am just a parent and I know that someone else is a parent like I am.

Tiff has a role
Cam has a role
Jordo has a role

so lets narrow it down that way.

who else has a role?

Between Mandie Phoq and JJ we have 2 townspeople and a witch, that help =)

Nope.

Between Phocq JJ and YOU we have one townsperson and a witch.

Jordan and Cam, i've known you for about 10 years. So Im going to stick to you like Glue.

From the beginning he has accused me of being a witch.

My vote is for KYLE.

I'm starting to think that Phoc is the witch, and Kyle is the tracker.

Although, while I was typing that up, Mandie posted her vote for Kyle. So I really just don't know lol.

Id be willing to lynch Phoq/JJ and roll the dice that even if we are wrong the roles can recover from the miss and we will have it narrowed down to 2 people, while only losing a townie. Just scares me that Mandie is sneaky enough to pull this off as the lone witch left.

Hey Cam, have fun running off to visit Tiff two nights ago? wink wink

I told you to vote for me and yall can debate it more

I really dont care LOL this game makes me want to pull my hair out.

Im frustrated the that three "innocent" people can't figure out if you are innocent or not. You piss me off in the game because you keep saying I could be a witch, yeah yeah fuck you I know from where you are sitting you are supposed to suspect everyone but Im not the freaking witch which is why I guess I am frustrated.

Quit looking at ME as a suspect and figure it out so this game can end and I can keep my sanity.

Thank You.
End Rant.

wink wink

I Retract my vote for Kyle.

So it's Mandie, Phoc, or JJ, at least in my mind.

Okay that helps see was that so hard Boys.....


Kyle is ruled out. Tiffani is right.

So yall have ruled out Jordo, Tiffani Cam and now Kyle

I ask again, what about Jackie and Phocq.

Jackie pointed fingers last round did she actually ever vote?

Tiffani, you thought Phoc was innocent once, do you still think that he is?

Mandie, I'm not saying you are a witch, but you definitely could be. I know a little bit about psychology, and you COULD be acting frustrated to gain sympathy, and throw us off your trail. If there even was a trail in the first place.

So yeah, I'm gonna wait a bit and see what else is posted from the people that aren't here right now.

Just see it from our POV Mandie, it seems all we have is your word at this point that you arent a witch. Im just trying to gather all the facts and figure a scenario where even if we are wrong on this lynch (2/3 chance) we can still recover and finish the work at hand of hangin this final witch

Which is why yall frustrate me.

I said it last round, I thought yall would be able to analyze my actions and thoughts.

ANd although I shouldnt give up, I am. Sorry

Imj going to watch justified now. Tall man... gorgeous Marshall....

Peace. Good Luck with yall's decision.

I went back and looked at each days final votes. I really cant see a pattern that sticks out to me for either of the 3 as being the definite witch. Phoq def seems like the most agressive of the three always looking for a lynch. That may just be his personality though, I dont really know him.

Wow, I just get home and open my computer and there are four pages.

First, I will tell you I am NOT a witch. I can promise you that and if you decide to lynch me it'll just be a wasted round. I have no role so I can't dispute Kyle, Tiffani, Cam or Jordan's roles. So, I have to believe they are who they say they are unless Phoc comes on and disputes a role.

With that logic and knowing I'm innocent, either Mandie or Phoc have to be the witch. I do have to say I have always believed Mandie's claims of innocence but then is a witch going to tell us she's a witch? Of course not.

Mandie, I know you get emotional but you have to understand people can't just trust your word, right? No matter how sincere you seem.

I will go along with a vote for either Mandie or Phoc. I don't think voting Kyle makes sense at all because even if he is a witch, which I doubt, Tiffani already told us she protected him and he can't be lynched so that would be pointless.

I reract my vote from Kyle




My vote is for Jackie.

Mandie Leigh wrote:

Jackie pointed fingers last round did she actually ever vote?

Yes, I did say I thought Stacie seemed the most suspicious last round. Even now, when I know she was innocent, I could look back at her posts and understand why she seemed suspicious. I would have voted but I knew we had plenty of time and I wanted to make sure I was voting the right way. I was out when all the votes came down. When I got home the round was over. You guys are such quick posters.