Witches 2 ~ Hocus Pocus Day 3

Good Observations though. You brought up some good points.

Tiffani wrote:

Last time I wondered if the witches were targetting Phoc because he was the missing witch, now I'm wondering if they were trying to paint him as the missing witch since we now know it was Virtuanno.

How do we know this, exactly? He was logged on within 24 hours prior to the deadline, I don't think it's that difficult to send in a name, so I am of the opinion he was not the reason for the no-kill. I certainly don't know what exactly happened, I just now know Virt was a witch. Perhaps we have a little slip here?

You have hit the nail on the head Tiff

derB wrote:

Tiffani wrote:

Last time I wondered if the witches were targetting Phoc because he was the missing witch, now I'm wondering if they were trying to paint him as the missing witch since we now know it was Virtuanno.

How do we know this, exactly? He was logged on within 24 hours prior to the deadline, I don't think it's that difficult to send in a name, so I am of the opinion he was not the reason for the no-kill. I certainly don't know what exactly happened, I just now know Virt was a witch. Perhaps we have a little slip here?

Well whatever, whether we know it or not, I was thinking the witches were trying to paint Phoc as the bad guy and since Virt was a bad guy, I truly believe that Phoc is innocent.

derB wrote:

Tiffani wrote:

Last time I wondered if the witches were targetting Phoc because he was the missing witch, now I'm wondering if they were trying to paint him as the missing witch since we now know it was Virtuanno.

How do we know this, exactly? He was logged on within 24 hours prior to the deadline, I don't think it's that difficult to send in a name, so I am of the opinion he was not the reason for the no-kill. I certainly don't know what exactly happened, I just now know Virt was a witch. Perhaps we have a little slip here?

Well whatever, whether we know it or not, I was thinking the witches were trying to paint Phoc as the bad guy and since Virt was a bad guy, I truly believe that Phoc is innocent.

Everyone was saying that it was an MIA witch that cause the no kill, both were online, both were capable of sending in a name. So whatever the witches's reasons, i really don't care. Whether one didn't send in a name, or they sent in different names to cause chaos or maybe they targetted the person the nurse protected, too much evidence points at Phoc being innocent.

YES! lets get this witch outta here

Like...?

For being an innocent person, you sure seem to know a lot of stuff Tiff...

I know it do I? So let me get this straight, since you are saying I KNOW this stuff for sure, you are verifying that I am correct? Which means you are telling me that you ARE indeed a witch? Because except for saying WE know, and then rewording it because that's what everyone said last round but when I say it, i'm an idiot, so I changed that to that's what everyone was saying, and now you're telling me i seem to KNOW a lot of stuff, and you can point your witchy finger with your little hints all you want, but I'm innocent, and I believe you are not.

I had been having a hard time reading DerB because we are close I think. But something has been buggin me about him, and the fact I can't read him, since the first round. And as much as I lurve me some DerB, I think i have to call it when I feel it ya know? And I'm feeling it.... and He hasn't convinced me that he is innocent. So, at this point in time he is my number 1 suspect. Having said that, I'd also like to state a few of my other opinions.

I think PhocQ and Tiffani are innocent.
I think Thian is innocent although maybe he has a role.
I think Kyle is innocent, I have thought this from the beginning. With all his accusations so early in the game and claiming to have "not been able to get a read on me" and then saying "thats what any good parent would do" , thats two different roles. I think he has a role but I dont know which one is really his.
Jackie, I dunno but my gut says you don't have a role.
Stacie, Jordan, Cam - Undecided. I don't have enough information from them to make any kind of judgement or come to a conclusion. (votes i need to relook at their votes)

Did I leave anyone out?

We wanna drag this round out longer so maybe witch number 3 shows thereself? On the flip side, a lone witch versus 8 are bad odds, Im good with it. That witch would have to be epic, and if we go through everything Virt and derB ever said it may be there.

I think you are right Kyle, there is no point in dragging this round out. I'll go ahead and put my vote on DerB.

thats 4, majority is only 6 now right?

correct

At the beginning of this round, it has a list of players, says there are 10 of us, it also states that to reach a lynch it is majority + 1
Does that mean 7?

6 make a majority, plus one is 7?

majority last round = 7 (half of 12 plus 1)

so majority this round = 6 (half of 10 plus 1)

derB, just vote yourself and save the final witch from revealing themselves... jus sayin, Big poppa needs a challenge.

Tiffani wrote:

Everyone was saying that it was an MIA witch that cause the no kill, both were online, both were capable of sending in a name. So whatever the witches's reasons, i really don't care. Whether one didn't send in a name, or they sent in different names to cause chaos or maybe they targetted the person the nurse protected, too much evidence points at Phoc being innocent.

It is also possible they sent in the same names, but were blocked isn't it??

That's what I wondered at first, everyone kept saying it had to be someone inactive, I thought maybe the nurse might have saved someone, or the seer investigated Sarah? is that the way it is, if Sarah is investigated a kill doesn't occur?

You see, all I have to do is ask for the 3rd witch to show themselves. ty Jordan, you are next

Kyle wrote:

You see, all I have to do is ask for the 3rd witch to show themselves. ty Jordan, you are next

I'm sorry, I don't understand?

I'm hesitant to vote for DerB because he seems to make a lot of sense in his posts. I really hate to lynch him and find out he's innocent.

And yeah Tiff, the seer can do that.

I suppose if we lynch derB, that clears phocQ even more, because I don't really think the witches would turn on each other when there's only 2 left. They need to preserve their numbers.

I'm going to go ahead and Vote derB and we'll see what comes of it.