Witches 2 ~ Hocus Pocus Day 4

BAH! go townies!!!

Oh No, not Thian......

Gawd, that sucks!!!

If we can figure out who the last witch is, thats it, we can end the game and win it for the townies.

Awww. That sucks. I hope nobody expects me to take care of Thian's kids for him. I don't even like my own.


I'm figuring at this point there is no excuse for us not to be able to figure out who the last witch is. Given all the roles, at the very least it should be easy to narrow it down to the witch and 3 parents .

Given Kyle's comments on Tiffani on day 2 and the fact I think her talking more openly about roles makes it less likely she has one. I think Kyle checked her out and got nothing. I think Tiffani is a parent.

Obviously Kyle has a role and given how sure he was about his call out of Derb, I'll guess he is the seer.

I'm going to guess the Tracker is either Stacie or Jordan. I was surprised the witch was able to make a kill last night so I'll guess one of those two chose incorrectly.

I think JJ is the nurse/repellant or whatever role. I don't really know why but I just feel like she has secretly been keeping us safe.

Not really sure but I'll guess Mandie is Dani the investigator.

And since I am not (edited lol) a witch, that really only leaves one of Cam or Jordan/Stacie as the witch. Cam has said a ton of things that have seemed very suspcious to me. He called out Kyle for his role, jumped on bandwagons for lynches and basically just been shady. lol

So yeah, them's my guesses.

PhocQ wrote:

And since I am a witch,

Freudian slip much?

Thian

While that is quite interesting Phoc, I'm not sure I agree with you about all the roles but it is obvious we should be able to get the witch. I have my own ideas of who I think have roles/are innocent but one person I think is not innocent and that I am voting for is Cam.

I vote for Cam

I am also voting for Cam


I need to go back and read some more, I remember making a post last round that sounded good to me lol But from the pain i was in, I have forgotten what I said already lol It totally sucks sucks sucks, I hope we get this right because the nurse obviously has no idea who needs protection each night

Id like to hear some arguements for someone to lynch other than Cam. Lets not rush to a quick lynch like we almost did day 2 w/o hearing from everyone first.

Id actually like to step up and defend Cam. I don't have time (as I'm at work) to go into detail at the moment but will when I get home. Just speaking up now so we don't rush into a lynch...

Im going to hold off on my vote. I want to hear from everyone before I make my decision. Stacie.... that includes you too. lol

I'm here.. Today was my daughters birthday, so I am sorry I haven't been around much, and on that note.. I have several plans this weekend, so I will try to be here as much as possible.

Sorry Thian, you will be missed.

I am not a witch. I will answer whatever questions you have. Not really sure what you want to hear.


Why is everyone so ready to lynch Cam? I think we need to be on the watch out for people who are pointing fingers right off the bat. I am not sure who I will vote for this round, I'm stumped. I didn't get to vote last round, because by the time I made it to the forum, it was closed. Everyone had already lynched DerB.

I also think we need to go back and see who DerB and Virtuanno were pointing fingers at.

yes actually, sorry to distract but we do have family plans this weekend etc for my niece's bday. Although i will only be partaking in tomorrow's lunch plans. I wish you luck Stacie with all those 2 year olds.



As for what you said Stacie,about the game, I think going to look to see what Derb has said in the past about people may help point us in the right direction. Was he ever against Cam, or Jordan?

Well, in the end, he voted for himself. However, at the beginning of the last round, seems like he pointed his finger a little at everyone. He seemed very wishy washy until others started to point fingers.

I feel strongly the final witch remaining has responded since my last post.

Stacie wrote:

Why is everyone so ready to lynch Cam? I think we need to be on the watch out for people who are pointing fingers right off the bat. I am not sure who I will vote for this round, I'm stumped. I didn't get to vote last round, because by the time I made it to the forum, it was closed. Everyone had already lynched DerB.

Well the reasons Jackie gave are exactly why I'm willing to vote him as well, and he was top on my suspect list last day time as well.

Ok Thian didn't even post last day round, so why would he be a target I wonder? I'm wondering if before Winifred was killed, she checked Thian out and discovered he had a good role and told the others about it which is why Thian was night killed. Because I'm not sure why someone would go after a quiet player last day compared to the louder ones. But who did he usually go after? Cam, wasn't it?

Kyle wrote:

I feel strongly the final witch remaining has responded since my last post.

So Stacie, Jordan & Mandie?

Yes you're right, Thian did go after Cam. Tiffani, I believe you're on to something here.

I vote to Lynch Cam

Kyle, if you honestly know who the last witch is, then just say so. It's one witch. The only way the witch cannot be lynched is if the Nurse protected them last night and I can guarantee you that Alison did not protect any of the suspects.
Also, Jordan, i hope you can get on and let us in on your secret soon. I have to wonder, would a witch jump in to save an innocent player to make themselves look innocent by chance?
This leaves Mandie & Stacie. I have to say I trust that Mandie is innocent, because there were times she stood up to take the side of innocent people, myself included, and I'm not sure 100% that a witch would do that, unless like I mentioned above, unless it means she looks innocent in the long run.
Stacie as a new player, I can't feel any vibes for her at all.
And Kyle, well I'm still here lmao so I think he's innocent, but then again, killing me would've probably put a target on him. So he could still be a witch. derB stood up for him over and over again, and maybe they planned that from the beginning. That they couldn't be witches because derB was protecting Kyle a lot, and then when the time came, Kyle would target derB or vice versa, and look innocent in the long run. But no one has disputed any "claims" that were made.

I just realized that we have a blocker lol roh ruh
Anyway, Dani & Emily were not killed which means that the witch can indeed be lynched, after reading the roles, it says the only way we can't kill a witch is if the witch sucks the lives out of these girls. GOOD.

I guess it's safe to say that Phoc could be right about Jordan, because if he tracked Cam last night and Cam did nothing, and someone died, that means Cam is not a witch.

I'm going to retract my vote for Cam until I hear more from Jordan.

Jordan wrote:

Id actually like to step up and defend Cam. I don't have time (as I'm at work) to go into detail at the moment but will when I get home. Just speaking up now so we don't rush into a lynch...

This post makes me feel Cam shouldn't be lynched. I retract my vote to lynch Cam.

Jordan, can't wait to hear more from you but until we do there's no rush. We can almost find our witch by process of elimination now.

I am leaning toward Stacie because after saying "Why is everyone so ready to lynch Cam? I think we need to be on the
watch out for people who are pointing fingers right off the bat." Two people had voted Cam at the point and I am always suspicious of people who say "pointing fingers" like it's a bad thing because that's what this game's all about. If you aren't pointing fingers you are doing nothing to help. Also, after Jordan's post (which was an obvious claiming of a role and knowledge imo) she votes Cam. Like maybe she's hoping for a fast lynch before Jordan has time to explain himself?

you gals wont regret those retractions =)